Really good

I work in the oilfield and can only wear these during the coldest days. If in the 20's, I'm getting hot pretty quick. Mine have been awesome and have zero flaws. I am 5'9, 190/195 and wear a medium short. I will say after washing for 2 years, they do shorten up.

Very unhappy. Zipper broke second day and carhartt won't get back to me

These were great when we first got them. Very warm. But after one wash, the zipper on the busted and is missing some of the little metal piece the zipper goes one.

My grandson who works for BNSF Railway loves them.Said he started warm and toasty while he walked the track at night.