Overall, I like it, although the sleeves are a little long (Size: Large) and there was a bit of wear (i.e., the start of those little worn holes that appear in denim jeans after they are worn and washed multiple times over the years) near three of the button holes. I considered returning it because of this, but decided to just put in a few stitches of compatibly colored thread to reinforce the fabric.

looks and fits great, everything I was hoping for!

Fits well (as expected), and offers the perfect weight plus wind- and water-resistance for fall and spring (or year-round in the Bay Area). I put it on over one shirt--long-sleeve if the high will be in the mid fifties, short-sleeve if it's going into the low sixties--and it can stay on all day without making me too warm or leaving me chilly.

Comfortable straight out of the box. Loose fit gives you plenty of work mobility without getting in the way of your job.

yea, just a great coat like all carhartt products.