I purchased six of these this past winter to replace the same that are 10 years old. Material is of lesser quaility. Collars are showing wear after one season. Better learn to sew because you will be replacing buttons. The centers of the collar buttons break and fall off. Replaced 40% of the collar buttons on six new shirts as of this review. Priced close to what I paid ten years ago but they are not the same shirts. I would rather have the same shirt even if it costs more.
Love everything about this shirt. Durable in the field, but very good looking in the office or for meetings. However, the best colors for this shirt are Midnight and Storm, and Carhartt is discontinuing them! Bring them back!
My wife Cindy purchased two (2) shirts for me (Brown and Green) .. these are by far the BEST shirts I have ever owned. They are heavier then most of the light, long sleeve shirts that I own and very durable. They look great, fit perfect, and seem to be very well manufactured. I will purchase more carhartt products in the future.
I have bought these shirts for my husband and brother for at least 10 years in two different sizes- same style. Last year the sizing changed and we had them for months before we realized they were way too small and not wearable so we don't know if the quality changed as well. It was a big disappointment. I started ordering them direct when the Canadian distributor no longer stocked tall and had limited stock. We have no access to try on before purchasing. They were their favourite shirts.
This is my new favorite shirt! Will definitely be getting more. Shirt is much thicker and more than more durable than anything else I own. For all the people complaining about Carhartt shirts decreasing quality, I would like to know what they are talking about because this shirt rocks! The only button-downs in my closet that come close to this level of quality are some older Eddie Bauer corduroys. Fits great, looks awesome, and feels very nice too. Thank you Carhartt...
This shirt is made of the thickest material which is the only kind of shirt my husband will wear. I think he would wear shirts made of sheet metal if he could. No other retailer can match the weight and quality of the material in this shirt (with the possible exception of fire retardant material). The workmanship and fit are also excellent. The shirt launders like a dream and is very durable. Even the dye is durable and this shirt doesn't fade like others.
Great Shirt! I wear one every day for work in a heavy duty maintenance environment. Over the past six months they have been regularly abused but still look good. No lost buttons, no loose threads and the cuffs show little signs of wear. I love the look and feel of the heavy twill.
This is a terrific shirt for work or to wear out for a casual dinner. I bought my husband one and then ordered two more online! The fabric is soft to touch yet durable, wears and washes well. It is a very handsome shirt and quality meets pricing.
i have several of these shirts now since they have replaced my previous brand and i consider them an upscale work shirt because they look nice enough for casual wear they launder nicely and look good straight out of they dryer i am an ironworker and am very hard on shirts but these have held up great just wish they were available in a tapered fit
I did have trouble with these shirts but I must say the company has stood behind their product. I know of few companies that would make the effort they did to assure the customer is taken care of. All I can say is they CARHARTT works at making a good quality shirt. I would recommend them.
My boyfriend spends most of his time working outdoors in all conditions. He has this shirt in every color; they're all durable and look good. No matter how dirty he gets them they come out of the laundry good as new. Plus he looks fantastic in them!
I've purchased over a dozen of these shirts through the years for my husband and he absolutely loves them! They are nice and heavy weight and thicken some with washing. The oldest ones (have had for about 5 years) have never lost a button nor ever had a seam give out either. Colors do fade after a couple of years but they still are durable. Won't buy my man any other! Well worth the price!
This is the shirt for the serious worker. Tough enough to stand up to the day to day of the jobsite, yet comfortable untill I'm done. The longer I have them, the more I love them. I want to look professional every day and this shirt helps me to do that.
I have one in each color. Wore them last winter and I liked them. Purchased the new color this summer and I imagine it will work just as well as the others. So far so good. I have tried many different brands over the years, these are the best.
Carhartt has contacted the customer to ensure satisfaction.
August 25, 2016
What a disappointment
My husband has been wearing these shirts for years. I just ordered two new ones and the quality is very poor in comparison to the original shirts. The fabric seems cheap and the pleat at the yolk, which gives more room for broad shouldered men, has been deleted. Think you need to find somewhere other than Nicaragua to have your product made!! I will not be ordering again.,
Carhartt has contacted the customer as well as shared the review with Product Design.
September 21, 2016
4 / 5
1 / 5
Shirts not what they used to be
I have bought these shirts for my husband for many years. The ones I have bought in the past months are not of the same quality as the old ones. My husband wore one shirt once and I washed it for the second time. I noticed the button has busted completely off the collar. The buttons seem to bust right in the middle. Not good considering how expensive these shirts are. I can't recommend these and am now looking for another brand that will work better. They also aren't as thick as they used to be.
like there products very much they are always right never have any problems they always fit perfect the sizes are what they say they are and the clothes are very durable would recomend them to all my friend
I bought this shirt for my brother, and it has "Original Fit" written on the inside collar. I bought a Large Tall, because the sleeves on the large regular were too short for my brother. The tag on the pocket just has Carhartt written on it. Hope this info helps.